Harris.bmpRiAA.bmp

While the big news on the music front last week was the Gabriel/Eno announcement, their celebrity may have overshadowed two other important news items. Coincidentally, these diametrically opposed viewpoints came public within a day of each other. One of them is a bit of a surprise, while the other has the smell of an old spin piece.

When looked at side by side, its apparent that only one of them can be right; You guess which one it is:

Beyond the Anti-Piracy Suits: Year-end news stories reported not only overall decreases in the unauthorized downloading of copyrighted music, attributed to lawsuits filed against individuals by the Recording Industry Association of America, but an uptick in music sales. And more lawsuits were filed by RIAA last week. However, this seemingly straightforward story is about more than merely suing people to encourage music buying. There’s a carrot here, too — not just a stick.

Compare that statement with this one:

Americans Think Downloading Music for Personal Use Is an Innocent Act: While the news media have been filled with stories about what some are calling “Internet music piracy,” a large majority of the American public views downloading music for personal use as an innocent act, and thinks the high price of CDs leads to a lot of downloading.

Fully three in four adult Americans (75%) agree that “downloading and then selling the music is piracy and should be prohibited, downloading for personal use is an innocent act and should not be prohibited.”

An almost equal 70% say, “If the price of CDs was a lot lower, there would be a lot less downloading of music off the Internet.”

I’ll end your suspense: The first excerpt was from Hilary Rosen, former chairman and CEO of the RIAA. The second clip was a 1/28/04 Harris Poll.

Break this down: It’s apparent that despite the best efforts of the RIAA, most of the country continues to perceive file sharing as OK. In light of the massive publicity that the RIAA has generated via their very high profile lawsuits, this is really quite astounding. Downloading may very well be the single biggest current act of civil disobedience in the United States — bigger than driving faster than 55mph, and certainly bigger than pot smoking.

Here’s another surprise: Despite several years of “education” by the RIAA, most Americans do not completely grasp the nuances involved:

The potential financial impact of downloading on musicians and recording companies may not be fully understood by the American public. Nearly two of three adult Americans (64%) agree that musicians and recording companies should get the full financial benefit of their work. While the music industry views downloading as an issue of property rights, agreement with the three statements reported on to this point is at virtually identical levels among Republicans and Democrats, and liberals and conservatives.

While only a small majority of adults (54%) agree, “downloading music off the Internet is no different from buying a used CD or recording music borrowed from a friend,” the differences by age are large. Younger people are much more likely to agree with this statement – 70% of 18 to 24 year olds and 66% of 25 to 29 year olds agree; and there is a decline with age – only 36% of people 65 and older agree with the statement.

ReThink Research noted that “this suggests the music industry is fighting an uphill battle in winning the hearts and minds of Americans to support prohibitions against downloading.” Somehow, the RIAA have failed to convince the public that there is a link between downloading and its financial impact on the recording industry.”

Who’d a thunk it: Suing your clients and calling them thieves is not a great business strategy . . .

Sources:
US public still believe downloading is harmless and should be legal
ReThink Faultline
Feb 2, 2004

http://www.rethinkresearch.biz

Beyond the Anti-Piracy Suits
HILARY ROSEN
WSJ, January 27, 2004

http://online.wsj.com/article/0,,SB107517375356212562,00.html

Harris Interactive Survey
The Harris Poll® #5: Americans Think Downloading Music for Personal Use Is an Innocent Act
by Robert Leitman, January 28, 2004

http://www.harrisinteractive.com/harris_poll/index.asp?PID=434

Americans Think Downloading Music for Personal Use Is an Innocent Act
Press Release, January 28, 2004

http://www.harrisinteractive.com/news/allnewsbydate.asp?NewsID=752

Category: Finance, Music, Web/Tech

Please use the comments to demonstrate your own ignorance, unfamiliarity with empirical data and lack of respect for scientific knowledge. Be sure to create straw men and argue against things I have neither said nor implied. If you could repeat previously discredited memes or steer the conversation into irrelevant, off topic discussions, it would be appreciated. Lastly, kindly forgo all civility in your discourse . . . you are, after all, anonymous.

90 Responses to “Americans Think Downloading Music is OK”

  1. sarlomey says:

    I really enjoy visiting your website and I think downloading is stealing. I think the music company should start suing people cue if not they will continue downloading and the music company will go down. I will come back to visit someday.

    Bye

  2. Jason says:

    Most americans think that downloading music should not be prohibited but you should realize that when people download music to burn to CD’s you take money from the industry. Im into the band thing and ive been trying to join a band so I can relate to this. when you burn music to a CD or download from the internet people not only steal from the industry they also steal from the bands which could put them out of the music industry which means no more music.thats how I feel about it.

  3. KALL says:

    SINCE THEY PUT THE SUPPLIES OUT THERE FOR US, SUCH AS KAZAA. AND NO ONE SHUT THEM DOWN YET AND STOP THEM I THINK WE SHOULD CONTINUE BURNING MUSIC.

    HEY IT’S ONLY FAIR.

  4. Donnie says:

    Personally,I believe that downloading is stealing, but that,s just my outlook on it. to each his own.

  5. Angie says:

    Downloading music may be said to be stealing but if we werent going to buy the music in the first place then how colld that me so..now that it’s free, if we like it enough, were more likely to purchase the CD.

  6. Angie says:

    Downloading music may be said to be stealing but if we werent going to buy the music in the first place then how could that be so..now that it’s free, if we like it enough, were more likely to purchase the CD.

  7. Tanika says:

    I don’t see nothing wrong with downloading music for their personal enjoyment. What I do see people selling loads of cds they have burned and making alot of money doing so.These are the ones that should be sued.

  8. Dave says:

    With the consolidation of the radio industry, there is NO GOOD PLACE TO HEAR & SHARE NEW MUSIC.
    With p2p, you can taste & sample whole songs, not just 10 sec’s worth, and will eventually lead to purchasing a cd IF (a big if) the cd is priced reasonably.
    I remember being able to go out and buy a cassette in the 80′s for $6-7.00. I don’t think that $10-11.00 is bad, adjusting for inflation. I could definitely see parting with that much at least once every month. However, when they start costing $13.00 and over, my interest in the CD, no matter how good the band, drops precipitously.

  9. VIRGINIA says:

    VIVA LA RESISTANCE!!!!

  10. Me says:

    ok if Cd prices was cheaper people would buy them.. here where i live they start out at 17.00 and go up some i have seen was as little as 14.95 but it also depends on the band how old the band is but if they are a big band with great music you are not going to pay less then 17.00 for the cd.. and then if you buy the cd you are mostly buying it for 1 or 2 songs… i have over 200 cds that i have bought for just 1 or 2 songs and that is crap. If they would make a machine that will let you burn a cd and put the music that you want on it at the stores then you pay for it there that would be so cool.. and you dont have to pay 17.00 for 1 song.

  11. They have that machine: An internet connected PC

    You can do that with Apple’s iTunes Music Store, or any of the other pay per song sites. Download 10-15 songs at 99 cents per, burn it to a CD — you are set!

  12. Abi says:

    Does the iPod just encourage illegal music downloading? Yes, I think it does. I have never even contemplated illegally downloading music either choosing to play it through a programme like Windows Media Player where you are unable to save the music to your iPod or copying my CD’s which I have bought. I have copied another persons CD however… Buying an iPod with so much free space for music encourages people to go on to illegal sites and download their music. I have downloaded music that i wanted but would not be prepared to buy. As a person I enjoy having an album with the album art and cover. I know that this is a problem and always feel guilty after downloading an album. The price of CD’s is phenomemal BUT i would be prepared to buy more CD’S if the price went down. iTunes is a good programmes but is comparable to the price i would pay in the shops. How much of the money that I pay them goes to the artists themselves? I’m reckonning not all that much.

  13. Melissa says:

    i think downloading music is ok as long as you don’t sell what you burn, i think that if people like the music enough to burn it that theya re more likely to buy the cd because most people burn the songs before the cd is even out.

  14. Stephanie S. says:

    You’re a bunch of losers! Downloading is fun but I don’t think we should be able to get it for free.
    Or like pay 9 cents for it.

  15. lydia says:

    Hey i dont think downloading music off the internet is a crime i think that it good because if they did not have downloading people would not listen to music very much so its good hey call me

  16. Keturah Reed says:

    I think that downloading music is a great way to gain free access to a number of things that you couldn’t get in a store. The only problem is, people only thing that they’re cheating the artists and its okay because they have more money than they even know what to do with in the first place. However, the problem is, we’re not only cheating the artist, we’re cheating the producers, song writers, and everyone else who depends on that song to either thrive or fail in order to determine their income. Its unfair to all of the people behind the scenes who aren’t rich and successful.

  17. unknownperson says:

    i’m doing a persuasive essay on this topic so can yall put some factual information on here to help me out?? thanks a bunch

  18. sabby says:

    you are all little rats!!!
    downloading in music is not bad but personally i’d rather goout and buy the music… thats what a true fan would do

  19. taylor says:

    you wee rats downloading is bad dont ya see i used to download but i stopped and travelled away from the bad and lead myself to the good so do the same travel with me

  20. Hansi says:

    A friend of mine told me about this place. I love it. I will recommend you to all my friends.
    See you again next time I surf around.

  21. Freedom. says:

    Screw the RIAA, down with the Man.

  22. Hommie A says:

    i think you are all fuckin bitches for buyin the cd
    it costs too much

    i just download

  23. Moe D. Lawn says:

    I think that downloading muic for free is OK!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  24. cody says:

    I think music dwnloading is kind of fucked in way because it’s screwing up the music biss a bit

  25. NIKA says:

    i think music downloading should be free because i barely even like all the songsa on a cd andf they are so expensive.. and musicians make WAY too much money.. n now they want more.. PLzzzzz

  26. Susan Klaas says:

    Very good work, really well done. See you again sometime at this interesting place. Say hi to all people around the world.

  27. xpliCitOne says:

    music artists started out wanting to be heard and now that they are they want the money? they already get money for their suveniers, concert tickets, ads, ect. they act like they dont already have 10 cars.

  28. denis says:

    i think it is stupid, and there is a chance mess up your computer, and get caught doing it.

  29. Matt Sisko says:

    I side with most of you on downloading new music , if the cd’s were priced rite the record companies would sell twice the quantity. But what about music that is over 20 years old, some of the older artist are no longer with us. Who should get their royalties? The record companies only get away with what we the public let them. If we don’t buy they al loose.

  30. dan says:

    The ipod dose not encourage the downloading of illegel music. The itunes for the ipod cost money and they want you to download there songs, which cost money. Some people talk about things they know very little about, so they shouldn’t talk about it if they dont know enoght about it. It’s sooo funny to see so many people say that the downloading of music is steal! lmao if your not going into a store and taking something off the rack and walking out the store not paying for it, how is it steal? Plus when you buy a set of blank cd’s there is a portion of the cd that goes to the artist’s/band so its not like they are getting any money. Some people are just idoits and don’t know what they are talking about, half of these people are on a bandwagon. If you download music and burn it onto a cd and sell it, you can get charged and pay up to 150,000 for each song, that is if you are caught! But people will always buy CD’s because the quality of the music is better and not everyone has a computer.

  31. Jeff says:

    downloading should be free!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  32. Alyssa says:

    I think downloading music is good, it helps artists get thier songs out. If someone dowloads a sond and it is really good they are more likey to go out and buy the cd because they already know they will like it. when people start selling it thats when the problem starts. Whats the differece between downloading music and buying? and they dont even get paid half as much as these artisits with millions of dollars who are complianing about downloading. I think people should enjoy music and when you have to pay $20.00 and more for a cd alot of poeple resort to downloading.

  33. Alyssa says:

    I think downloading music is good, it helps artists get thier songs out. If someone dowloads a song and it is really good they are more likey to go out and buy the cd because they already know they will like it. when people start selling it thats when the problem starts. Whats the differece between downloading music and buying a used book or getting one at a libray? do you hear the writers complaining?they dont even get paid half as much as these artisits with millions of dollars who are complianing about downloading. I think people should enjoy music and when you have to pay $20.00 and more for a cd alot of poeple resort to downloading.

  34. Jack Be Nimble says:

    If God created us not to be able do it, then it wouldn’t happen.

    Besides, back in the day muic was free, so why not keep it that way? You know, there are much easier ways to keep artists music off of P2P anyway instead of just going around intimidating P2P users.

  35. Tim says:

    I just got a summons for having music that i bought on my computer that was in a shared file. these companies did a search on peoples computers who use limewire, winMX, kazaa, and imesh. i think that should be illegal. what if i had very important documentation in that folder? the folder was password protected anyways so no one could access any file without a password. i think all the music industries should go to hell and stop picking the poorest people to sue because they know we cannot afford a lawyer.

    http://www.problemsinamerica.com/main/viewforum.php?f=21&sid=90bb6bd3901361b151d676893e979ae3

    help support me in my case by posting your comments in the above URL!

    Thanks

  36. Tom says:

    I think that download is fine b/c my dad work for itunes and i still downalod song for free he said it fine to do it so go head lol Later anytime for helping u

  37. John says:

    Downloading music off the internet is OK. If you burn and sell that’s a different story. There is no difference between downloading off the internet and recording off a radio station and burning onto a CD. If you are going to use it for personal use then what’s the problem? they just make a big deal about it.

  38. Nas says:

    i agree with the idea of free downloads. I dont get why many peole kno about these P2P programs and are doing nothing to stop it. Also, i think doing things like ripping cd’s is the exact same, yet things like media player (which comes installed on almost every computer) has programs for ripping and burning. This only encourages the “theft” of music even more. They shud let it be, let people download and stfu. All the “man” has done is run his mouth, i think the only way for results to show is for them to take action.

    so, i dont kno bout u… but in not gonna stop

  39. Clare says:

    I think downloading music is ok maybe like one or two songs off of a c.d but if you download the whole c.d then you have a problem. I mean a song there and a song here is one story but a c.d there and a c.d here then it will turn into downloading a movie and selling it, before it even comes out. So I think just downloading songs is ok, but lets not get carried away.

  40. jomamma says:

    i think its perfectly ok

  41. California Teen Magazine is by teens for teens in Southern California. We want to do an article on illigal downloading. If you, or someone you know got sued for downloading and want to be heard e-mail us at contact@calteen.com. Or if you ahve anything else to add just let us know.
    Thanks!
    http://www.calteen.com

  42. Draconas says:

    LOL, this is absolutely an awesome forum, let me share my opinion.

    My personal philosophy on downloading music is this:
    If you own it (I.E. have purchased the CD) it’s ok, if it’s something you cannot get on a publicly purchaseable CD (I.E. Remixes and Non-Importable Music from other countries – Yes it is something that exists) it’s ok, however, if you want to sample it to see if you like it before you buy it that’s ok but if you don’t like it, delete it and if you do like it then pay the money and get the CD, or at least the single of the song if you don’t like the whole thing. Don’t use it as a way to freeload from talented individuals, use it as a way to boost those peoples careers by listening to all you can and buying what you like. I do think that suing everyone who has ever downloaded or shared a file is going to be a nearly impossible task and a downer for everyone. Instead think of a positive solution, if people are downloading something more than purchasing it, find out why they aren’t willing to pay for it, do surveys, if you ask me the quality of music in both production and overall guidlines to good music getting produced has gone steadily downhill. It used to be that when I liked one song or single from someone, I usually liked the whole album (maybe one or two out of 16 or so songs that I might skip over rather than listen to) Nowadays, the single off the album is the only good song on the thing (and sometimes that even isn’t really true, or there is one song that is really good on a CD that they never publicize instead churning out a bunch of crap for singles and making you wade through them to hear the good stuff) and the rest of the CD makes a decent coaster. Perhaps a combination of lower CD prices, as it’s pretty obvious that the production costs on a CD AREN’T that high, and making sure that most if not all of the CD is quality… (have a producer listen to it over and over and over, if they can’t stand listening to it then why would they expect us to) will help keep the music industry afloat, not berating every person who has downloaded music?

    Anyway this has been my two cents. Thanks for listening.

  43. Elizabeth says:

    I think that music downloads rule major. I think that its fine just to download a couple of songs. I understand people needs money off a cd but so does people who is buying cds. Its a waste of money to buy a cd for one song so why not get it for free?

  44. Ashley says:

    I agree that downloading music is alot easier in-expensive and that I myself have downloaded songs before it was a big deal but, but I would rather pay my bands and government what they ask for what I enjoy than have my bands dissapear because they were ripped off of their own music, the illegal part of downloading isn’t what stops me it’s the fact that I have respect for the great bands like Metallica, Korn, Guns n Roses and all those other bands that totally rock. and would like to see them continue

  45. Former Downloader says:

    I admit that i used to be a heavy downloader… But that all changed once i got a letter in the mail saying that i was liable for being sued by some company if i dont get rid of everything… yeah that scared me a little bit…..However, How is the music business different from other businesess? They produce a product for a profit.. with the changing environment, many businesess go through downsizing periods. since people are wanting to listen to music digitally now a days, why cant the music industry conform and reasses thier strategies to fit our wants and needs. the industry is faceing a retrenchment and we have to bend over backwards to go out of our comfortable homes.. get in our gas guzzlung cars and buy a CD for $15 and up.. and it might not even be that good!. what a rip off and u cant even take it back.. its like its not worth anything anyway since it fully depreciates when u leave the store! anyway i luve downloading.. and the industry will just have to find another way to deliver the music… they get paid too much anyway.. hah

  46. Michelle says:

    yeah okay so i’m doing a paper on this…. I think that downloading music / movies / etc. is OK… why? well because.. 1. when you purchase CDs or DVDS or anything else, the money endorses and contributes to the negative Hollywood image of materialism, greed, sex, violence, and superficitality. (which pressures young men and women into being thing, beautiful, and perfect which leads to life threatening situations) 2. Downloading doesn’t greatly impact the funds of celebrities and producers because they already have more than sufficient incomes to support themselves. 3. It is unavoidable… the public will always find a loophole in the system to continue and rebel. And besides they don’t even catch half the people that do it… so what do i suggest to the music business? deal with it!

  47. michael says:

    well i think it not ok but if u put on the internet then that mean it ok because if u don’t want people to download then take it of the internet then and plus if u have a ipod the u have to download music then

  48. Jay says:

    I know exactly why some of the music industry is fightin against file sharing.

    They are exposed without profit

    What I Mean by this is most of the artist,

    keyword “most”. Are putting out garbage music. They

    might have one or two or if their lucky 3 songs that are

    decent at most. Well on the radio they get to pick

    what songs you listen to, so of course they are going

    to put their top song on the radio and expect you will

    go buy the overpriced CD or Tape at the store. This is

    why Artists are ok with the radio. Now that we have

    the internet. We get to choose what songs we want to

    hear all the songs in much less quality but alteast we

    can sample to see if its worth spending that much on a

    a cd/tape ect. So now that we have a choice in the

    matter its illegal, was it ever illegal to turn on the radio

    and listen to their hits over and over and tape them on

    a cassette tape? No it wasnt, now that we have the

    choice to listen to what we want its a problem. that

    should be illegal if you ask me.

    yeah selling copies of stuff should be illegal, but

    listening to something like we have always done be

    illegal? give me a break

  49. Sean says:

    What’s the difference between me borrowing a friend’s CD and copying it, or me downloading the entire CD of Kazaa? I didn’t pay for it either way. One is illegal, the other isn’t.

    This has been going on since 8-tracks went out the door and audio cassettes were made available to the public. What’s that.. like.. almost twenty years now?
    Nobody made this big of a fuss about it when it first started happening back then. Why start now?

    Bunch of freakin’ whiners, and greedy bastards. Any person in the music industry who complains about it is. If someone likes the music enough, they’ll buy it, even if they just downloaded half of it for free. I do, just to support the bands I like.

    I agree with Jay. This is all silly, and it’s about money for people who make more money than most of the people posting here will even see in a lifetime and that’s sick. Fuck ‘em all.

  50. robert says:

    Only internet hating politians think that music downloadong is illegal. I mean they probly made it in the first place and now they say “Dowloading music is illegal”. I agree with Sean that who ever is complaining are a bunch of whinning people who now make a fuss about it for nothing.

  51. john says:

    music downloading is good if download just a few songs,but if u download a lot of c.d s then ur in a problem.

  52. Megan Kinsmen says:

    NO good comes of it.. it is a shame to all things holy.. stop the madness.. stop the pain.. buy the music, buy your happiness.

    my sincerest regards
    megan

  53. Fatty Fatty Bombom says:

    this website is RUBBISH, it has bin written by an american though!

  54. Even Fatter Fatty Bombom says:

    This website is CHEAP! Put some more money into it!

  55. Even Fatter Fatty Bombom says:

    This website is CHEAP! Put some more money into it!

  56. The greatest downloader ever says:

    Been downloading since Napster 1.0. I have no moral dilemma with it, especially when I see the way musicians spend their money. Look at how previous artists lived, like Davinci, Shakespeare, and even Bob Marley. They did not go live their lives in wealth and spend dollar after dollar just because they had it. And most artists didn’t make nearly the money that artists do now, so they should be happy we appreciate their works enough to spend the time to dowload it.

  57. U all are gay says:

    You are all stupid losers u spend all ur time on gay websites like this one

  58. go to hell says:

    downloading should be legal, i mean why the hell do we have to pay freaking 17 dollars on a CD then live on cabbage stew for two weeks. And Britney Spears spend 1 million dollars on a valentino dress wears it for like a day then flushes it down the toilet. Is that fair?

  59. dennis teel says:

    downloading music is NOT stealing if you wouldn’t by the downloaded songs to begin with..to steal something means there’s a loss somewhere..you’re not stealing profits if you wouldn’t buy the downloaded music to begin with..i download music via limewire,but even if i didn’t i wouldn’t buy the music retail..MOST people that download fit this description…people need to understand the definition of stealing..if the RIAA isn’t losing something(or the artists)then it’s not stealing.i downloaded a robert palmer song tonight..would i have bought it if i hadn’t had the oppertunity to download it free??? NO!
    the RIAA didn’t lose anything and furthermore neither did robert palmer! most music downloaders that i’ve talked to,fit the same description. IMHO it defines the majority of music downloaders

  60. mason babb says:

    I think it is ok. It is there so why not use it. All the people who think it is wrong just dont do it, dont worry it is other peoples business if they want to get music.

  61. Jeff says:

    Is downloading music wrong? I personally don’t think that downloadings wrong because music artists have enough money as it is. A couple of dollars wont hurt them. They make millions through concerts and CD’s are starting to become out of date. There is no way that the government or anyone else is going to be able to shut down every program that allows you to download music for free. They should just give up and leave us alone because they are never going to be able to stop this.

  62. Kahlua says:

    Nothing is wrong with downloading and it should be made legal. You people going around taking people to court n suing n shit, quit the whining and get the stick outta your asses.

  63. Phil Mcrutch says:

    i think that downloading music is stealing because u are gettin the song for free instead of buying it in the shops or entertainment shops

  64. Sergio says:

    I personally think that Downloading music has helped many artist on a come up. There are plenty of people who discover an interest in new music and artists that they’ve never heard of, or heard before simply by downloading. Downloading is a form of promotion for artist and don’t feel like it is hurting their pockets. I think that the record companies are the millionaire theives that are suing regular middle classed people for money that the artists themselves will never see anyway.

  65. Sergio says:

    I personally think that Downloading music has helped many artist on a come up. There are plenty of people who discover an interest in new music and artists that they’ve never heard of, or heard before simply by downloading. Downloading is a form of promotion for artist and don’t feel like it is hurting their pockets. I think that the record companies are the millionaire theives that are suing regular middle classed people for money that the artists themselves will never see anyway.

  66. Sergio says:

    I personally think that Downloading music has helped many artist on a come up. There are plenty of people who discover an interest in new music and artists that they’ve never heard of, or heard before simply by downloading. Downloading is a form of promotion for artist and don’t feel like it is hurting their pockets. I think that the record companies are the millionaire theives that are suing regular middle classed people for money that the artists themselves will never see anyway.

  67. Sergio says:

    I personally think that Downloading music has helped many artist on a come up. There are plenty of people who discover an interest in new music and artists that they’ve never heard of, or heard before simply by downloading. Downloading is a form of promotion for artist and don’t feel like it is hurting their pockets. I think that the record companies are the millionaire theives that are suing regular middle classed people for money that the artists themselves will never see anyway.

  68. Sergio says:

    I personally think that Downloading music has helped many artist on a come up. There are plenty of people who discover an interest in new music and artists that they’ve never heard of, or heard before simply by downloading. Downloading is a form of promotion for artist and don’t feel like it is hurting their pockets. I think that the record companies are the millionaire theives that are suing regular middle classed people for money that the artists themselves will never see anyway.

  69. Sergio says:

    I personally think that Downloading music has helped many artist on a come up. There are plenty of people who discover an interest in new music and artists that they’ve never heard of, or heard before simply by downloading. Downloading is a form of promotion for artist and don’t feel like it is hurting their pockets. I think that the record companies are the millionaire theives that are suing regular middle classed people for money that the artists themselves will never see anyway.

  70. Sergio says:

    I personally think that Downloading music has helped many artist on a come up. There are plenty of people who discover an interest in new music and artists that they’ve never heard of, or heard before simply by downloading. Downloading is a form of promotion for artist and don’t feel like it is hurting their pockets. I think that the record companies are the millionaire theives that are suing regular middle classed people for money that the artists themselves will never see anyway.

  71. Sergio says:

    I personally think that Downloading music has helped many artist on a come up. There are plenty of people who discover an interest in new music and artists that they’ve never heard of, or heard before simply by downloading. Downloading is a form of promotion for artist and don’t feel like it is hurting their pockets. I think that the record companies are the millionaire theives that are suing regular middle classed people for money that the artists themselves will never see anyway.

  72. Sergio says:

    I personally think that Downloading music has helped many artist on a come up. There are plenty of people who discover an interest in new music and artists that they’ve never heard of, or heard before simply by downloading. Downloading is a form of promotion for artist and don’t feel like it is hurting their pockets. I think that the record companies are the millionaire theives that are suing regular middle classed people for money that the artists themselves will never see anyway.

  73. Andrew says:

    I think downloading music is awsome cus I can steal from others I get such a rush Its almost like smoking pot I get so excited then I start cutting myself and drink the blood while mastrabating to the music ahhhhhhhhhhhhhh it feeels sooooo goooooood

  74. cody says:

    I think downloading music is ok I meen look at all the songs thay put out there its not like there going to go broke they can cry me a river cause I dont give a crape.!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  75. Summer says:

    so like OMGZ i totally love the music dling, its like soo cool! like eff, i love my free music, like usher uhhh hes such a hotty!, but newayz im so in for dling free music!… well duh! wo wouldnt be! its sooo cool and who wants to spend money on cds? like duh some people are only teens!… we def dont have enough money for cds! we have to go buy like expesive clothes and all that!
    soo yeye im soo in for this whole music dling thing! WOO GO USHER (l)

  76. dan says:

    Stealing would incorporate the debilitation of the stock of a certain product. It would prevent another person from purchasing that item. No one loses a downloaded song for it is merely a copy of a file and no one is prevented from buying the CD. In fact, a case can be made that downloading can improve sales. If someone hears about an emerging artist, I highly doubt they’re going to go purchase the CD right away. What are they going to do? That’s right, download it from a third party source in order to see if it’s worth the money or not.

  77. johnathan says:

    i think that the artist are getting paid by other things anyway so it shouldnt matter if there records dont sell! theyre just being greedy!

  78. Frank says:

    that guy matt sisko is stupid, yea you could buy music from i tunes but if you want you can drag stuff from limewire and put them on your ipod. i know i never downloaded music and now i do it like their is no tommorrow! i find stuff i will never hear in a cd and stuff that was just made for a tv show. how would i get to hear that if i did not download it?

  79. Frank says:

    that guy matt sisko is stupid, yea you could buy music from i tunes but if you want you can drag stuff from limewire and put them on your ipod. i know i never downloaded music and now i do it like their is no tommorrow! i find stuff i will never hear in a cd and stuff that was just made for a tv show. how would i get to hear that if i did not download it?

  80. Larry says:

    music downloading allows me to get music I can’t regularily find at a music store. i love it

  81. In the U.S. and I have freedom says:

    i think downloading music is an awesome thing. people who think its a bad idea, fuck you then. if you dont like downloading, then dont. go pay 18-20 dollars and buy a CD, i could just get my music from the internet…. for free. dont us, americans already pay too much for evreything else? if you dont think so, then buy a CD or even a collection of them.

  82. Slash says:

    Honestly, I dont think downloading music is bad, but im always at constant fear of being sued. I usually sample 1 or 2 songs and then I consider buying the album. And its not the artists that are behind the suing, its just the RIAA sucking out every possible dollar and coin from the consumers pockets.

  83. Jennifer says:

    My personal opinion of downloading, it is wrong, and that you should not do it. My first reason why downloading is wrong it’s because if artists don’t get paid for producing music or movies you listen to and watch they pay money to produce and create if they are not getting paid back they will not make any more movies or any more music. M y second reason is that it is unfair for other people to pay money for CDs and other music/movies and etc; while other people get them for free. My Third and final reason why downloading is so wrong, is because when you take something that you didn’t create or help make or take what isn’t yours, you are stealing.
    Celebrities make music and create movies using money, if they are not getting money back because you think you are smart for downloading off the internet you are wrong you are jut fooling yourself because celebrities pay to produce or create something. With you downloading of free artists and actors are not getting their money cut and their will be no money for them to produce another movie or create music.
    It is unfair for people to pay for the CDs and movies in the store while other people are just downloading from the internet for free. It is unfair because while people are downloading (which is illegal) for free, hard working people that earn minimum wage is spending there money right and not breaking any laws while doing that. When you download of the internet is if just like stealing from a store it is wrong and you should never do it.
    well there are my reasons Bye!~xox~

  84. Larry says:

    My biggest complaint against the music giants is that they are so slow to get new tracks available to buy! Several times, I have tried to buy a song that they are playing on the radio and it is just not available LEGALLY! And yet, there it is for download if you wish, as an illegal download! This is nuts. Make the music available to us and I will buy it!

  85. Jean says:

    If I like the artist good enough I would and do buy their album. Otherwise, I have better things to spend my hard-earned money on. so-so artists and oldies get downloaded for free. I wouldn’t have payed for them anyhow no matter what. I can take it (their songs) or leave it.

  86. A Person says:

    This is a really good site, and I thank you so much for having it! I have a school project and we have a debate unit at school- and the teacher choses our debate issue for us (and if we are for or against). I’m supposed to be against people who download copyrighted music having to face leagal action. This really helped me. Thanks! (I do think that downloading is stealing. )

  87. muui says:

    I’m doing an essay about downloading and I need to know who wrote this so I can acknowledge their work.

  88. chandra says:

    screw the music industry

    and if you thnk dnloading music is wrong…then thats on you

    leave the rest of us alone about it