Checking Back in with Taleb
Good Evening: U.S. stocks today recovered almost half the losses they suffered yesterday. Credit for today’s light volume comeback goes to the combined effects of a recovery in Asian equities (China’s CSI 300 was up 1%), some analyst upgrades in the tech sector, and earnings beats by some retailers. What the future holds for U.S. equities is anyone’s guess, but many will be looking to the charts for clues. If the averages really are set to correct, then the S&P 500 should run into stiff resistance between 990 and 1000 during the next day or two. A close above 1000 will probably reset the clock on any near term correction, but should the widely watched benchmark continue to close below the 4 digit mark, then a test of the 950 level is likely imminent. A break of 950 will set up tests of support between 900 and 875. Below those levels will put the cat once more among the pigeons, but it’s too soon to speculate about a resumption of the primary bear market. As for reasons why such a possibility is not out of the question, perhaps it will help to check back with Nassim Taleb to get his latest views.
Since it was angst about Chinese equities and the implied lower demand for commodities by that nation that helped pressure stocks during the previous two sessions, an overnight rally in China helped stabilize stock prices around the world. Accordingly, our index futures were already in positive territory this morning when Home Depot and Target reported better than expected earnings (Saks reported a narrower than expected loss, though TJX disappointed). These retailers recorded punk top line sales, but both managed to cut costs and manage inventories well enough in Q2 to outstrip analyst expectations. Analysts were also responsible for a pop in technology stocks, with the most noteworthy upgrade coming for the entire mobile handset sector. Thus inspired, the NASDAQ then led the indexes higher for most of Tuesday’s trading, though it was interesting to see Google sit out the festivities. One day does not make a trend, but a leader like GOOG should not be a wallflower.
Stocks opened to the upside and were 0.5% higher during the first hour of trading. The economic data seemed to have little impact on today’s events, with PPI and housing starts coming in well below expectations. Perhaps there was some confusion as to whether falling producer prices were either good news or bad at this point in the cycle, and the same could also be said about the housing data (see below). While overall starts fell short of the mark (and remain far, far below peak levels), the glass half full contingent pointed to rising single family starts for the 5th consecutive month as unalloyed good news. Though I’m glad folks are gainfully employed while erecting these structures, the last thing an oversupplied housing market needs is more homes.
If any of the foregoing bothered equity investors, they didn’t show it. Stocks rallied 1% to 1.5% by mid day before settling in to a dull and narrow range. The averages went out near their highs, with the Dow (+0.9%) lagging, while the 1.7% gain in the Dow Transports led the way. Treasurys also played their “counter-trend Tuesday” role in giving up about half of yesterday’s gains. Yields rose between 2 and 5 bps. The dollar followed suit in falling after two days of gains, while commodities made it a clean sweep by rising. A 3.7% rise in crude oil set the pace as the CRB index rose 1% today.
Nassim N. Taleb needs no introductions to regular readers of these commentaries. I’ve read both his books, and recounted at length some of the interesting views he espoused at Barry Ritholtz’s conference back in June. I missed his appearance on CNBC last week, but a video and a capsulated version of his comments from that interview can be found below. I will let Mr. Taleb speak for himself, though I will say that sound-bite T.V. is not the best format for his powerful intellect. He is at his best when he writes about a topic, or when he is allowed to discuss it at length. Being wedged in between commercial breaks on Squawk Box does him little justice.
Though he revisits many of the topics he discussed back in June (like swapping debt for equity to aid the deleveraging process), he raised a few eyebrows when the subject turned to Fed Chairman Bernanke. Mr. Taleb is stoutly opposed to Bernanke’s reappointment, saying Bernanke, Geithner, and Summers have been part of the problem — so why reward them? When pressed for just who he would support to replace Mr. Bernanke, Taleb offered up Paul Volcker. I would love to see Volcker back at the helm, but he’s been marginalized inside the administration by Mr. Summers. Besides, like my favorite choice for the job (Jim Grant), Mr. Volcker would probably turn the offer down. Given how our politicians and the voters who elect them have little stomach for making hard choices, the job is almost impossible to do well these days. Any warm body can print money; the hard part is dealing with the consequences.
– Jack McHugh
U.S. Markets Wrap: Stocks, Oil Advance as Target Tops Estimates


Tweet
Facebook
Reddit
Digg this!





August 18th, 2009 at 10:59 pm
Going long for tunraround tuesday turned out to be a good play but I’m in Taleb’s camp and I’m remaining cautious.
Imo, it’s a shame what’s happened with Volcker. When I heard they were bringing him in to play a role in the administration, I was excited. Unfortunately, Mr. Volcker is being grossly underutilized and we’re all the worse for it.
August 19th, 2009 at 9:02 am
@Cohen
Right about the history of “turnaround Tuesday”.
I was actually a little lucky yesterday. I’m positioned mostly in cash at the moment, but I have a few small chips on a 10% correction taking place into September. I’m expecting something in the 914-930 range.
I had the chips in place before the Monday selloff (but I didn’t chase it further). I just lowered the stops (from 1014 down to 1008). I was actually looking to add a few more chips back on on a move to 997-1,000 (but I had another small target at 990 which I made good on).
Even though. I’m not convinced that we’re going straight down to test that correction level… It feels to me like the 976 level is going to be a level that the market wants to do some work at for a few days…
It’s a crazy place to play!
August 19th, 2009 at 9:56 am
That was a great little interview with Taleb. Personally I though the most interesting thing among many talking points was when he pointed out that The Debt Has Not Gone Away. In other words, many of the structural imbalances that caused the crisis remain in place. The boogeyman really is under the bed this time.
SPX 875-880 is the level of greatest importance – it has historic significance and is most likely to attract buying.
August 21st, 2009 at 10:24 pm
While I have a lot of time for Volker there is little that he or anyone else can do because the problems are structural and there is no way to make fiat currencies retain purchasing power for very long. The US is a bankrupt nation and its currency is a shadow of what it used to be when it was actually backed by a monetary commodity. If you want to make it through the volatility keep some cash on hand, avoid debt that can be called in on short notice, buy lots of gold and enjoy the ride.