New York Magazine’s cover: “Things are better than they seem. Honest.”
Some of you are now thinking: “Uh-oh, another happy mag cover. That spells trouble for the stock market.”
Let’s review if this meets our requirements for a major warning, a contrary indicator sufficient to halt the rising equity markets. As it turns out, the short answer is no.
Here are the details:
If you recall 2 weeks ago, we discussed what the premise of the magazine cover is:
1. Mainstream — not business — publication
2. Well understood concept that is reaching a climax
3. Asset price gains
Rule #1 was easily met. New York magazine is a non-biz, mainstream publication.
Second, while the stock market has rallied hard from March 2009 — up 82% or so — this cover is not cheerleading that rally. So we haven’t really met the subject of rule #3.
But the main reason this fails as a magazine cover contrary indicator, is our rule number 2. We haven’t had a run of optimistic news. QE2 would not be necessary if everything was hunky-dory. Things have been mediocre at best.
The psychological angle of the cover indicator is simply this: Some well understood concept is climaxing just as it makes the front of a mainstream media outlet. That is not met here.
Indeed, the entire concept behind this issue of NYMag is “Hey Buddy! It aint THAT bad! We know things are tough — try to look at the bright side of life.
Compare that with “Why we are gaga over Real Estate.” Hence, we do not have a contrary magazine cover indicator at work here.
You may return to your prior tasks . . .
Uh-Oh: Barron’s Cover “Bye Bye Bear” (October 31st, 2010)
Tale Of Home Prices Told Through Covers Of TIME (September 14th, 2010)
Please use the comments to demonstrate your own ignorance, unfamiliarity with empirical data and lack of respect for scientific knowledge. Be sure to create straw men and argue against things I have neither said nor implied. If you could repeat previously discredited memes or steer the conversation into irrelevant, off topic discussions, it would be appreciated. Lastly, kindly forgo all civility in your discourse . . . you are, after all, anonymous.