More on Munis, Detroit, Bloomberg, Whitney & Wilson
David R. Kotok
Cumberland Advisors, July 24, 2013



In our recent commentary on municipal bonds and Detroit, we argued in favor of buying the highest-grade AAA tax-free municipal bond It currently yields more than the corresponding taxable US Treasury obligation.

Meredith Whitney, Muni Cassandra emeritus (ae?), weighed in against Munis (FT) and used the Detroit default to say her version of “I told you so.” Bloomberg reported both sides of the argument.

Readers may seek Whitney’s positions and her history of Muni-forecasting on their own. Our position is clear: do the research and buy the bonds that make sense. There are many of them. This is an idiosyncratic market of $3.8 trillion; painting it with a broad brush is a mistake.

We took the position that the default history of the true AAA-rated tax-free municipal bond has the same default history as the US Treasury bond: neither has ever defaulted.

We offer many thanks to Bloomberg and especially Dave Wilson for picking up our story and for featuring a chart showing the upside-down relationship between tax-free Munis and Treasuries. See, “Municipals Seen as Cheap After Detroit Filing: Chart of the Day” .

When the tax-free AAA bond has a higher yield than the taxable US government bond, it is not priced according to credit risk or the tax code; instead, it is priced by a dysfunctional market. We used the State of Utah and Yale University as examples of issuers of such bonds.

Subsequently, our friends at Strategas Research Partners published a research note on July 22, 2013, articulating a similar concept. The source for their data is Moody’s Investor Service. We are subscribers to Moody’s, utilize Strategas Research, and find both of great value.

The back-up information for our assertions comes from Moody’s. The AAA-rated (by Moody’s) tax-free US municipal bond has a 0.00% default rate one year after issuance, five years after issuance, and ten years after issuance. Historically, the bond has experienced zero defaults. There is no evidence that any true AAA-rated tax-free municipal bond has ever triggered a default in the state and local government debt sector in the US.

Remember, we are referring to the natural rating of the bond. We are not referring to those bonds that were insured by various bond insurers and thus elevated to an AAA rating because of the bond insurance. Bonds that were rated AAA only because of the insurance have defaulted, but the underlying ratings of those insured bonds always fell below AAA. No true AAA credit ever needed bond insurance to sell a new issue.

Readers may want to note that there is a slight default experience in AAA-rated corporate bonds. It is small, but it is there. The fact is that there is a difference between state and local government bonds and corporate bonds of the highest credit quality. In our discussions, we restricted our comments to state and local government bonds; we did NOT address corporate bonds.

The bottom line is that the true AAA tax-free US municipal bond scale now offers bonds at yields that are higher than the corresponding Treasury bond. This is true at maturities throughout the yield curve, from the short end of 2 years to the long end of 30 years and at every stage in between.

We reiterate our conclusion of yesterday. We continue to favor the high-quality tax-free municipal bond. We think such bonds are cheap. We also note that the overall credit mix of state and local government is improving. That happens when the economic recovery progresses.

Joe Kalish of Ned Davis Research notes the improvement. Using year-over-year data he cites that “Total Tax Revenue” is up 5.1% to a new high of $1.421 trillion. Property tax revenue is up 2.6%; Sales taxes up 4.9%; individual income taxes up 10.3%; corporate net income taxes up 1.3% and other taxes up 4.5%. The “other” means motor fuel, tobacco, alcohol, licenses, death and gift taxes, etc.

Our bottom line: high grade, tax-free bonds are really cheap and their credit support is improving. Score one for Munis; score zero for Detroit; score evenhandedness for Bloomberg media in reporting. We will leave the Whitney scoring to our readers.

Let me add a correction regarding another matter. Bloomberg has indicated it will cover the gathering in Maine, but it will not be broadcasting live on Friday, August 2, 2013. There will be ample media coverage of the event by a number of sources. We are not sure if there will be live television coverage. We will keep readers posted of any changes.


David R. Kotok, Chairman and Chief Investment Officer
Cumberland Advisors

Category: Fixed Income/Interest Rates, Think Tank, UnGuru

Please use the comments to demonstrate your own ignorance, unfamiliarity with empirical data and lack of respect for scientific knowledge. Be sure to create straw men and argue against things I have neither said nor implied. If you could repeat previously discredited memes or steer the conversation into irrelevant, off topic discussions, it would be appreciated. Lastly, kindly forgo all civility in your discourse . . . you are, after all, anonymous.

6 Responses to “More on Munis, Detroit, Bloomberg, Whitney & Wilson”

  1. RW says:

    Kotok is spot on. I’ve invested in high quality muni’s for many years and, once I learned enough to do my own homework, avoided insured muni’s as overpriced w/ insurance that was unlikely to payout in a large-scale default.

    I have nothing more to add about Ms Whitney: I do pay attention to analysts but only when I am confident they are operating in their primary area of expertise (if I invested in financial sector corporates Ms Whitney would probably be on my short list but I don’t).

    Bottom line another broad sell-off in quality muni’s, particular one that leads to yields greater than taxable bonds, was and remains another buying opportunity.

    NB: Even though I profit from it now and again I generally deplore the rhetoric of apocalypse and decline not only because, in a sense, it puts me in a boat uncomfortably close to those who profit from misinformation, fear and hate — evangelicals, pundits, charlatans, revanchist politicians, crypto-fascist loons and their cousins, etc — but because at its heart it is a lie and a (potentially) fatal distraction; we are not a great country in some significant respects but we could be given more cooperation and less bullshit.

    “Our achievements speak for themselves. What we have to keep track of are our failures, discouragements, and doubts. We tend to forget the past difficulties, the many false starts, and the painful groping. We see our past achievements as the end result of a clean forward thrust, and our present difficulties as signs of decline and decay.” -Eric Hoffer

    • RW says:

      Neglected to clarify: Even though I profit from it now and again I generally deplore the rhetoric of apocalypse and decline that frequently accompanies or even initiates these kinds of market over-reactions

  2. [...] the lower values, I recommending buy some tax-exempts in the August issue of Retirement Watch. Here’s another explanation of why this is a good move for value investors who want some income [...]

  3. Sandy the Swede says:

    D. Kotok,

    In general,do the tax-exempt munis you buy, or advise your clients to buy, include those over 7-year maturity?

    Also, would you be able to point me to any studies which show effects on value of munis vs top-tier dividend stocks in an increasing rate environment? Most of my retirement portfolio is allocated to dividend stocks. Although I am quite diversified as to sectors, I am not so much as to stocks vs bonds. I am not a sophisticated investor and would welcome any advise; from you or the other folks responding to your article. Many thanks.

  4. [...] In a followup guest post on the Big Picture blog, Kotok offers More on Munis, Detroit, Bloomberg, Whitney & Wilson. [...]

  5. [...] Treasury Yields More on Munis In a followup guest post on the Big Picture blog, Kotok offers More on Munis, Detroit, Bloomberg, Whitney & Wilson. In our recent commentary on municipal bonds and Detroit, we argued in favor of buying the [...]