One of the more interesting aspects of the market in 2014 is how much it has managed to defy expectations. Consensus has been consistently wrong; indeed, it seems that any time there is an agreement of sorts on just about any issue, the opposite has happened.

Merrill Lynch’s legendary strategist Bob Farrell put together “10 Rules for Investing,” and rule No. 9 states that “When all the experts and forecasts agree — something else is going to happen.” That certainly seems to be the case so far this year.

Consider the following cherry-picked anecdotes in support of Farrell’s dictum:

No. 1. Rising-rate environment. It seemed like all any investing year-in-preview article could talk about was rising interest rates: “How to Adjust a Bond Portfolio in a Rising-Rate Environment,” “Investments To Watch In A Rising-rate Environment” and others graced my inbox the past month.

It was clear that rates had nowhere to go but up (didn’t they?).

The only problem was that we began the year with the 10-year Treasury at a bit higher than 3 percent, and its yield proceeded to fall to as low as 2.6 percent.

No. 2. Worst February start for stocks in 32 years. At least, that was what they were writing a week ago, after a loss of more than 300 points in the Dow Jones Industrial Average on Monday, Feb. 3. A weak bounce the next day emboldened bearish writers. But then the Dow had triple-digit gains on Feb. 6 and again the following day. In sum, after the worst start to the month of February — is there even a February Barometer? — the market finished the week with gains.

I was as bearish as one could be in 2007 and 2008, but markets were already wobbling. I can’t imagine how punishing an environment this is to be a bear.

No. 3. Gold miners and Treasuries were the worst sectors in 2013. Treasuries had a dismal year in 2013, recording their third-biggest annual loss in four decades. Their saving grace was that they weren’t gold-mining companies, whose stock prices were cut in half last year. Consensus was just as negative this year.

So how have these two done? In January 2014, Treasuries had big gains; the 20-year bond rose 7 percent. And gold miners jumped 17 percent.

We never know what the future holds. When all the experts agree about what is going to happen next, it might be fruitful to consider taking the other side of that trade.

Originally published Here



Category: Investing, Really, really bad calls, Rules

Please use the comments to demonstrate your own ignorance, unfamiliarity with empirical data and lack of respect for scientific knowledge. Be sure to create straw men and argue against things I have neither said nor implied. If you could repeat previously discredited memes or steer the conversation into irrelevant, off topic discussions, it would be appreciated. Lastly, kindly forgo all civility in your discourse . . . you are, after all, anonymous.

4 Responses to “Beware Consensus: When to Ignore the Investment Experts”

  1. DrFish says:

    my anecdotes tell me the vast majority is bullish

    • VennData says:

      If the market is in equilibrium, then it’s 50/50. If the market is not in equilibrium, then it moved already.

  2. Willy2 says:

    - But we have seen the bottom in interest rates in mid 2012 !!!! Perhaps we’ll see rates go a bit lower (e.g. 2.5% or 2% for the TNX) but the overall trend is – from now onwards – & IMO clearly UP !!!!
    - It sounds like one B. Ritholtz is now a bull ??? Or a “cautious” bull ?
    - Since the start of 2014 a number of my (credit market) indicators did make a turn for the worst.
    - Consensus ??? The consensus I see is still too bullish. (See above).

  3. [...] at The Big Picture blog of Barry Ritholtz he has a piece along the same lines warning about consensus, including a reference to the 10 rules of investing which includes Rule [...]