Posts filed under “Corporate Management”
“We are not done on the cost side . . . We think we need to keep raising the bar on that.”
So says Bill McNabb, CEO and Chairman of the Vanguard Group. The firm, managing over $3.1 trillion dollars in client monies, has long been known for its obsessive focus on keeping costs low.
In a wide-ranging 2-hour interview, McNabb noted the institutional advantages Vanguard enjoys, and why he intends to keep pushing costs lower: The firm is a mutual, owned by its investors, and not beholden to shareholders. McNabb maintains this unusual corporate structure gives them a 30-40 per cent price advantage over publicly traded competitors. He says the firm’s relentless focus on costs have “resonated at a level with investors” that even McNabb is surprised by. Quote Intel co-founder Andy Grove, McNabb states “You cannot get complacent.”
The phenomenon has become known as “the Vanguard effect.” Any time the investing giant enters a new market, costs to investors decline. McNabb add that competitors are “getting smarter” about cutting fees sooner, rather than “losing market share” to Vanguard.
F. William McNabb III joined he Vanguard Group in 1986. At the time, the firm ran a mere $20 billion dollars. At different times, he managed each of Vanguard’s client facing divisions. He rose through the ranks, eventually taking over the top job from Jack Brennan, a mentor of his. He became the firm’s 3rd chief executive, after Brennan and legendary Vanguard founder, John Bogle. His immediate previous job was managing director of the institutional and international businesses.
A story that has become legend around Vanguard involves McNabb’s ascension to CEO. When the firm began its internal search for Jack Brennan’s replacement, many of their managing directors were interviewed for the job. At the end of the interview, the candidates were all asked the same question: “If you were not CEO, who would you like to see running the company?” Just about all of them suggested McNabb.
No Layoffs for Vanguard Employees During Great Financial Crisis
The timing of McNabb’s start was auspicious: he began in August 2008, just 2 weeks before Lehman and AIG imploded, and the great financial crisis entered a new phase.
During the crisis, the firm had three priorities: maintaining well-positioned portfolios of safe securities, keeping their investors from panicking, and assuring the Vanguard’s 12,500 employees that the firm was stable.
McNabb thought the company was well positioned to ride out the financial crisis. Their exposure to the kinds of structured products that were causing issues at most iBanks was minimal. However, following the Lehman Brother bankruptcy filing, signs of investor panic were rising. Most notably, Vanguard’s call volume began to spike dramatically during the crisis. In order to prevent their fund holders from doing something they might later regret, in October of 2008 McNabb posted a webcast explaining why panicking into market turmoil was not an especially good idea. It was downloaded 100,000 times in the first 24 hours.
Despite the call volume, investors transactions were lower than normal. Investors were hungry for calm and rational information, and this was a salve.
Another concern was the message employees – “crew” at Vanguard, and yes, everything there has a nautical theme – might be subconsciously sending to investors. The sheer volume of Wall Street layoffs had put many on edge, and McNabb revealed that Vanguard instituted a new policy in the midst of the financial collapse. While much of Wall Street was laying people off, the Malvern, Pennsylvania firm handled market stress differently. The new CEO announced a “No-Layoff” policy. “We said to our people ‘Don’t worry about your jobs – You all have jobs, and you are here to serve the client. Stop worrying, no one is going to lose their jobs over [the financial crisis]; We want you focused on being here for the client.”
It had the intended effect. Inside of Vanguard, that tone helped with the client interactions. “People had confidence when they were talking to clients” McNabb added. Since the crisis ended, Vanguard has since added 2000 new employees.
Active Manager Selection criteria
Although the firm is well known for its indexing – it accounts for about 65 percent of their assets – they also manage about $1 trillion dollars in active portfolios. McNabb described the way they seek out and select managers to run these monies. Some of the criteria are surprising.
We want to find firms that have “great talent retention, low employee turnover and excellent succession planning.” Even though none of these attributes speak directly to the investing process, it reflects a specific firm culture that is readily translatable into better performance numbers.
But track records matter less than process verified by data. Prior to hiring a new manager, they look for easily explainable investing process that is consistent, backed up an intense “portfolio attribution analysis.” Consistency between the explanation of the investing process and the results is a key aspect.
Advice for Millenials
McNabb also had some advice for Millenials, and others starting out their career: Live below your means, save early, and get exposure to diversified global portfolio.
Executive compensation is in the news again as the Securities and Exchange Commission gets ready to issue new guidelines on pay disclosures. As mandated by the Dodd-Frank Act, the new rules are supposed to provide “greater transparency and allow shareholders to be better informed” about executive and director compensation. Transparency is certainly a good first step. But…Read More
Since CEO compensation is back in the news, I thought we might want to revisit this collection of excess via Bailout Nation: Pre-Crisis Financial Company CEO Compensation • Lehman Brothers Chairman and CEO Richard Fuld Jr. made $34 million in 2007. Fuld also made nearly a half-billion—$490 million—from selling Lehman stock in the years before Lehman…Read More
Click for the full report. Source: Bloomberg From Bloomberg: Business schools are supposed to produce graduates who have the abilities companies need most. But corporate recruiters say some highly sought-after skills are in short supply among newly minted MBAs. As part of our ranking of 122 top business programs, Bloomberg surveyed 1,320 job recruiters at…Read More
NEVER TRY TO CORRAL THE CUSTOMER People balk at being controlled. Once you place limits, the public abandons you or finds a way to circumvent what you are doing. Give people the opportunity to do more, to expand their horizons, to share. Once you tell them what they cannot do, you’re screwed. This is why…Read More
Kind of like the Supreme Court. You vote for some guy who says he’ll lower your taxes, but the truth is this President gets to appoint a Supreme Court justice who serves for life and when a case comes up long after the exec is gone, you find out that the court is tilted in…Read More