Posts filed under “Data Analysis”

Why I don’t buy the 4.5% Unemployment Rate

Where is the wage pressure?

That’s the question on my mind as we await today’s NFP. Yesterday saw a stronger than expected ADP Report, which whacked bonds and sent yields back over the 5% level; The 10 year closed at 5.144%. A prime mover: growth in service industries, which accelerated to the fastest pace in 14 months in June.

The Fed will be closely watching the data for signs that Average Earnings are rising, as a gauge of potential

Which brings us back to our original point: If Unemployment is actually as low as its been reported by BLS, then there is no slack in the labor market. We have a situation where demand is outstripping supply. In the Oil market, that sends prices higher. In Agricultural commodities, the same thing occurs. Indeed, in every market I can think of, when Demand is greater than Supply, prices rise. That’s Econ 101: prices should be rising robustly in that environment

Yet we see little evidence that wages and salaries are moving appreciably higher. Outside of bonuses and stock options, most wages have been pretty stagnant. For most of the past 4 years, they had been falling on a relative basis to inflation. Its only the past few quarters or so that hourly wages have risen at the rate of inflation or better.

A sign of a slack labor market is sluggish wage gains. Which is pretty much what we have been seeing.

The WSJ’s Ahead of the Tape column looks at the same issue, and asks a different question:

The Federal Reserve says measures of inflation have
improved lately. But it’s still worried that there’s little slack in
the economy, which could ultimately push prices and interest rates
higher. A key measure of slack is the unemployment rate. When it gets
very low, it can be a signal of labor shortages that create wage and
price pressures.

The labor market appears to have weakened a bit.
Through May of this year, surveys of U.S. businesses show they added an
average of 133,000 nonfarm jobs per month to their payrolls, according
to the Labor Department, down from last year’s average of 189,000.

Yet even though job growth has been slowing, the
unemployment rate isn’t budging. It is expected to come in at a
relatively low 4.5% for June, around the level it’s been at for nine
months. This is all the more striking because the survey of households
that the Labor Department uses to calculate the unemployment rate shows
especially paltry employment gains through May this year. Those paltry
gains suggest the unemployment rate should be rising.

His take is that since NFP gains have been on the low side, we should see unemployment tick up. My view is that all these Quarters of low unemployment should have sent wages skyrocketing, late 1990s style.

Yet neither has happened.  I cannot help but wonder why . . . 

Where’s the wage pressure?


chart courtesy of economagic


A few other things to watch for:

1) ADP data showed private sector job creation of 150k. That is the
number of total NFP the economy needs to merely keep up with population
growth and immigration each month. Watch for a celebration of mere population growth.

2) The June number enjoys a healthy Birth Death adjustment.  Bill King noted that "Last June the BLS created 166,000 (175k Prelim) Net B/D Model jobs out of thin air."


UPDATE: July 6, 2007 8:39am


"Nonfarm payrolls increased 132,000 in June, after
swelling 190,000 in May and 122,000 in April, the Labor Department said
Friday. Previous reports showed job growth of just 157,000 in May and
80,000 in April. Monthly job growth has averaged a robust 145,000 so
far this year. The unemployment rate was unchanged last month at 4.5%.

Average hourly earnings increased $0.06, or 0.3%, to
$17.38. That was up 3.9% from a year earlier, suggesting tight labor
markets still aren’t putting much pressure on labor costs."

A few notable data points from the release:

• B/D Adjustment was +156k

• Education and health services were strong at +59k, as was Leisure and hospitality +39k and Government +40k

• Construction employment was up by 12,000  (WTF?)

• Professional and business services were down 9k


ADP Employer Services Says U.S. Added 150,000 Jobs
Shobhana Chandra
Bloomberg, July 5 2007

Help Wanted: A Labor Report With Some Slack
Justin Lahart
WSJ, July 6, 2007; Page C1

CES Net Birth/Death Model

Employment Situation

Category: Data Analysis, Economy, Employment, Federal Reserve

How Is Retail Doing?

Category: Consumer Spending, Data Analysis, Economy, Retail

How Narrow A Nasdaq Rise?

Category: Data Analysis, Investing, Markets, Technical Analysis

Your Choice in Media Determines How Uninformed You Are

Category: Data Analysis, Financial Press, Psychology

Gaming the Data: Realtors Fudging the Numbers

Category: Data Analysis, Economy, Real Estate

CDO Hedge Funds = Enron ?

Category: Credit, Data Analysis, Derivatives, Finance, Hedge Funds, Markets, Psychology

Sub-Prime Housing Problems Limited to Just 7 States

Category: Data Analysis, Psychology, Real Estate

Who Owns Troublesome CDO/CMOs?

Category: Data Analysis, Derivatives, Financial Press, Hedge Funds, Real Estate

Housing Deterioration Continues

"The housing market
has continued to deteriorate throughout the second quarter" and "the
supply of new and existing homes has continued to increase, resulting
in declining home prices across our markets.

As Lennar looks into the third quarter and the
rest of the year, it continues to see weak, and perhaps deteriorating,
market conditions’ and expects a third-quarter loss."

-Lennar President/CEO Stuart Miller



Case Shiller Home Price Index, Year-over-year price changes
Source: S&P


As the chart above shows, the S&P/Case-Shiller House Price Index fell the most it has in 6 years. Dropping 2.1% y/o/y, this is the index’ 4th consecutive down month. Home prices are still up 26.5% from 3 years ago, and 8.8% from 2 yrs ago.

CNN/Money reports that "While sales picked up from the early part of the year, they tumbled
15.8 percent from May 2006 – marking the 18th straight month of
year-over-year declines."

This index differs from the pricing data from the Office of Fed’l Housing Enterprise Oversight (OFHEO) in that it includes the homes in all price ranges — OFHEO pricing data only covers "conforming mortgages" which doesn’t include most of the upper end of the housing market.

Meanwhile, Home Inventory continues to rise: The WSJ reported the number of homes on the market "increased 5% in May, adding to a glut
in many parts of the country and threatening to push prices lower as
the housing market keeps tumbling."

This amounts to a 15 year high of home inventory. And, all this inventory is not going away anytime soon. At current sales levels, the annualized housing sales rate has slipped below 6 million — 5.99 — a four-year low.


Read More

Category: Data Analysis, Economy, Real Estate

LEIs: Is the Economy Poised to Expand?

Category: Data Analysis, Economy, Employment, Psychology