Posts filed under “Think Tank”

Recession Over & All Banks Pass the Stress Test?

Good Evening: Just when the U.S. stock market seemed ready for a round of profit-taking ahead of Friday’s nonfarm payrolls figures, investors decided to throw caution to the wind. Apparently deciding that the recession and the stress over the banking system would soon be in the rearview mirror, market participants once again stampeded into large cap stocks in general and banks stocks in specific. If these forecasts come true, then perhaps everyone will soon be wondering what all the fuss has been about. Maybe both Jeremy Grantham and “the Warren Buffett of Mars” can give us some food for thought after such a curious day.

U.S. Stocks Gain as Banks Surge, Jobs Report Beats Estimates

When I went to bed last night, U.S. stock index futures were down more than 1%. Whether this downdraft signaled some imminent profit taking or was due to an early release of a negative Wall Street Journal article about the banks, I don’t know. The futures started to come back early this morning when the Challenger Job Cut report showed a downtick in the number of large scale layoffs in April. Worries about Friday’s jobs report then all but evaporated when the ADP employment report was released an hour before trading began in New York. ADP opined that less than 500,000 people lost their jobs last month, a figure well below consensus forecasts. Even though ADP’s track record in predicting the payroll numbers has been spotty, stock futures scrambled back and were soon up on the day. Just like that.

Recession in U.S. May End in June, Claims Signal: Chart of Day

After jumping more than 1% at the open, the major averages settled back toward unchanged. A weak NASDAQ held back the other indexes for a while, but continued levitation in bank shares eventually won out. Stories like the one you see above proclaiming an imminent end to the Great Recession also played a role in the rally. The averages pushed unevenly higher for the rest of the day, and it looked to me like more than a few managers were trying to play catch up. More than a few individuals were active, too, and many of them seemed to be liquidating their rapidly shrinking double-short and triple-short financial ETFs. The KBW Bank index (BKX) rose another 11.5%. It may not have been a total capitulation by the shorts, but it has been the most heavily shorted names that have been rising the most since the March lows. By day’s end, the NASDAQ’s 0.25% gain lagged the others, while the Dow Transports (+ 2%) led the way. Treasurys were mixed after a solid 10 year note auction; the dollar fell 0.5%,; and another leg up in energy prices pushed commodities up even more than equities. The CRB index rose 2%.

Geithner Says Banks’ Stress-Test Results Will Be ‘Reassuring’

Rumors about the Treasury’s “stress test” results swirled all day, and then the story you see above came out just after the bell. Apparently Treasury Secretary, Tim Geithner, will appear on the Charlie Rose show tonight and say that all 19 banks that were tested are “well capitalized”. Huh? If so, then either the stress test was a complete joke, or its been re-jiggered to be flattering enough to the banks to enable them to hit the market with secondary offerings. We have likely not heard the last of the stress test, but many already wish the whole concept had never been introduced.

The Last Hurrah and Seven Lean Years, by Jeremy Grantham, GMO
(Registration required)

More valuable than anything coming out of our Treasury Department in 2009 is Jeremy Grantham’s latest Quarterly Letter (see top). Meant to show investors just how hard it is to predict the future when the forces of de-leveraging and money-printing are still colliding, Mr. Grantham’s piece is at once both bullish and bearish. For readers who get confused about just where he stands on the economy and the stock market, Mr. Grantham summarizes his whole piece in the Appendix. He uses a simple decision tree that starts with the probability the U.S. economy recovers in late ’09 or early ’10 (in his opinion, 80%). The rest of his forecasts flow from there, but he does allow for a wide range of outcomes. Such is the life of a prognosticator when the unwinding of the largest credit bubble in history is met with the largest government stimulus in history.

A True Outsider’s Perspective
A True Outsider’s Perspective Revisited

Finally, I promised last night to finish the latest conversation in the ‘True Outsider’s Perspective” series of commentaries. Last night left off with our eager broker-salesperson (BS) promising to structure the ideal trade for the “Warren Buffett of Mars” (MB)

BS: Thanks for taking my call again. I’m eager to learn what your ideal security looks like so we can set about creating for you.
MB: First, I would like the highest quality credit available, one that assures my investors will be paid back. Your Federal Reserve has a printing press, right? It ensures all obligations of the U.S. government are paid in full, right?
BS: Yes; our government won’t ever technically default because the Fed can always print as many dollars as are necessary to pay off U.S. debt in full. So you want Treasurys?
MB: No, the yields are far too skimpy and inflation is a risk down the road
BS: Uh, you want us to buy you some TIPS, then?
MB: No, thanks, at least not at these levels. I would need to see real yields above 3% before I sense a margin of safety in those securities. Your government has always displayed an unfortunate tendency to underestimate the inflation calculation which help determine the total return on TIPS.
BS: Then I’m confused; what kind of U.S. government security do you want? Or are you after some sort of equity hybrid?
MB: No, your equity market has overshot where fundamentals tell me they should be priced. Since I know you prefer pictures, take a look at these charts of some markets that have struggled to delever after a period of over-investment:
BS: Wow; I see what you mean. Let’s get back to creating a bond for you.
MB: Reading some history, I’ve seen that your Treasury has previously issued obligations denominated in foreign currencies, right?
BS: Yes, but I don’t think they’ve issued those so-called “Carter bonds” in more than 30 years
MB: Good — we won’t be breaking new ground, then. But I don’t want to be paid off in Swiss Francs and the German Mark has gone to currency heaven. I have an undervalued currency in mind.
BS: Whatever; what coupon rate are you expecting to be receive?
MB: Are you familiar with some old Freeport McMorRan bonds that had their coupon payments tied to the price of gold?
BS: No, but I’m sure our research department knows about them, and we have a great structuring department that can customize a note for you that’s tied to the price of gold.
MB: Good — then here’s what I want: A 10 year note, issued by the U.S. government, denominated in Chinese Yuan, and with a semi-annual coupon set at 3% that is tied to the price of gold. If gold averages less than $900/oz. during the coupon period, then the bond pays 3%. For every $1 rise in the average gold price above $900 during each coupon period, however, the coupon steps up 1 basis point (i.e. $950/oz. pays 3.5%, $1000/oz. pays 4%, etc.).
BS: Excuse me? A Yuan denominated Treasury note with a coupon tied to gold?
MB: If there’s a problem issuing in Yuan, I’ll settle for Canadian dollars. Ottawa seems like a good steward of its currency.
BS: No…it’s just that…how will you pay for this note?
MB: In gold, up to half a trillion dollars worth at current prices. But your government has to keep the yellow metal in escrow at the World Bank and agree not to sell any until the note is paid off. No tricks.
BS: Let me guess — Mars is on the gold standard?
MB: Don’t be silly; our currency is based on energy consumption units, much like your BTUs. A currency denominated in energy units gave us the incentive to innovate. We are now energy independent. The gold is a relic from an earlier monetary standard and this investment idea gives us a chance to monetize what would otherwise remain inert.
BS: We can’t structure this! We’re not the U.S. government, and I very much doubt the Fed and Treasury will agree to these terms.
MB: Why not? Half a trillion will finance your budget deficit for at least a few months, and the initial coupon is 1/8 below the 10 year note your government auctioned off just this afternoon. Besides, I’m willing to be a good guy about it and agree to a maximum cap on the coupon of 20%.
BS: Uh, we can’t…I mean, why don’t you just let us issue you the same note on the same terms? At least then we’ll get paid for this trade.
MB: I don’t want the credit risk, but if you can’t handle the negotiations with your government, then don’t worry. I’ll just call Goldman Sachs. A nice gentleman there tells me the direct lines installed by Bob Rubin and Hank Paulson still work. In fact, I think I’ll give Goldman a ring. THEY can structure anything!
BS: No, wait!
MB: Goodnight…

– Jack McHugh — I will be attending a family event tomorrow night. This comment will resume next week.

Category: Markets, Think Tank

Congress Quietly Moves Pecora Commission

Tucked into an anti-fraud bill moving through the House and Senate is a Pecora-style commission with subpoena power.  The negotiations are based on the Senate version of the bill, and the Senate version has the commission in there.  I excerpted the section on the commission, you can see the full bill here:

Comments, thoughts, etc are always welcome, though in this case there’s probably not much I can do from my position.

Read More

Category: Legal, Politics, Think Tank

Picture du Jour: Stock markets – it’s all about confidence

Picture du Jour: Stock markets – it’s all about confidence A key requirement for the recent stock market gains to be more enduring and for the bear’s corpse to be put to rest, is the restoration of investor confidence. A few comments regarding this issue are highlighted in this post. As shown in Sunday’s “Words…Read More

Category: Psychology, Technical Analysis, Think Tank


ADP reports that 491k jobs were lost in the private sector, much less than expectations of a fall of 645k and a big improvement from a revised -708k reading in March (down from 742k). It’s the smallest job loss since the -352k figure in Oct ’08. Small and medium sized businesses continue to see the…Read More

Category: MacroNotes

How Do You Raise Capital Without Having to Raise Capital?

According to the leak du jour, BAC needs $34b in equity capital in order to absorb the losses estimated in the ‘stress test.’ Considering that they’ve already received $45b in preferred stock from the US taxpayer, an accounting maneuver of converting that to common can, Voila, cure their capital needs without raising a penny of…Read More

Category: MacroNotes

A True Outsider’s Perspective Revisited

Good Evening: After yesterday’s launch into space, U.S. stock prices spent Tuesday settling into a comfortable, if slightly lower, orbit. The economic data out today continued to portray a slowing rate of economic decay in the U.S., enough so that some bulls are proclaiming the recession might be over and some bears are rethinking their…Read More

Category: Markets, Think Tank

Stress Tests & Tim Geithner’s Bar Mitzvah

May 5. 2009

Thursday is stress test day. Not on a treadmill, but it may just as well be so.

We are now going to add some Geithner-Bernanke-Summers-esque formula of bank strength or weakness assessment to an already long list that includes Tier 1, Tier 2, TCE, and CAMELS and BOPEC. Tier 1 and 2 capital measures are released by banks in their public disclosures. TCE (tangible common equity) can be calculated from public documents.

Two other ratings are kept confidential. They are critical to regulators; and, in an affront to democracy and transparency, we are not permitted to learn them. Banks are not permitted to reveal them and the penalties for doing so may be harsh. Welcome to modern banking in America.

The BOPEC acronym stands for the five key areas of supervisory concern: the condition of the Bank Holding Company’s (BHC) bank subsidiaries, other nonbank subsidiaries, Parent company, Earnings, and Capital adequacy. BOPEC ratings are assigned according to an absolute scale, from the highest rating of one (indicating strong performance) to the lowest rating of five (very poor performance).

CAMELS ratings are assigned to banks within a bank holding company. Since the condition of a BHC is closely related to the condition of its subsidiary banks, the off-site BHC surveillance process includes monitoring recently assigned CAMELS ratings. The CAMELS system is used by the three federal banking supervisors (the Federal Reserve, the FDIC, and the OCC) and other financial supervisory agencies to provide a convenient summary of bank conditions at the time of an exam. The acronym CAMELS refers to the six components of a bank’s condition that are assessed: Capital adequacy, Asset quality, Management, Earnings, Liquidity, and a bank’s Sensitivity to market risk.

For a critical discussion of the coming stress test environment see Dick Bove’s guest commentary on Cumberland’s website: . We thank Dick for giving our readers access to his essay. We agree with him.

Read More

Category: Think Tank

How best to deal with debt?

Ben Bernanke and the FOMC have the fed funds rate currently at zero and with a straight face in the Q&A today, he says he’s committed to price stability. He has one unspoken goal in his policies and that is to inflate our way out of this current economic malaise. The Fed and Treasury are…Read More

Category: MacroNotes

FusionIQ Market Statistics

Market internals continued to be stellar with the NYSE registering an up to down volume ratio of 19.2 to 1, while advancers beat decliners by a ratio of 5.7 to 1. On the NASDAQ up volume bested down volume by a rate of 5.19 to 1, while advancers bested decliners by a 3.47 to 1…Read More

Category: Technical Analysis, Think Tank

LIBOR continues its drop

Another day closer to the release of the bank ‘stress test’ brings us another leak in the morning papers and today reveals that 10 of the 19 banks MAY need to raise capital and/or convert preferred to common in order to improve the TCE ratio. The relevance of the outcome is only important for those…Read More

Category: MacroNotes